Published on

​Book Review: Climate Clangers: The Bad Ideas Blocking Real Action by Jennifer Rayner.

​My favourite climate read from the festive season:
Climate Clangers: The Bad Ideas Blocking Real Action by Jennifer Rayner.
Book Cover: (Green) Jennifer Rayner - Climate Clangers: The Bad Ideas Blocking Real Action
Rayner stated that we cannot fix the massive problem of #cimatechange by relying on the same social, political and economic structures that got us here in the first place.  We have left it too long and let the risks mount too high to follow the path of incremental change.  We need to be flipping the switch to warp speed, but the three bad ideas detailed in the book are holding us back from taking action at the speed and scale that Science demands.
 
Rayner notes that these climate clangers are more like perspectives or conceptual frameworks that usually go unsaid and unnoticed because they're so embedded in how politicians, policy makers, businesses, and maybe some of us think and view the world, blinkering us from what is necessary and what is possible for tackling climate change right now.

The three climate clangers are:
  • That our economy must keep growing as fast as it always has as we decarbonise.
  • That Net Zero accounting can keep Global Heating within survivable limits. and
  • Looking at the cost of action but ignoring the cost of inaction.

Each of these clangers is ceremonially discredited in turn by Rayner and valid alternatives proposed.
Our economy is measured by GDP, which is the sum of everything produced and sold for money, including all wealth / profits going overseas.  So, fossil fuel exports by overseas companies inflate the GDP but bring little terms of direct economic contribution (jobs, taxes) to the country, whereas electrification and solar PV reduces costs to families and businesses but is bad for GDP even though it's great for Australians.

The paradigm of net zero puts the focus firmly on requiring businesses to balance their carbon ledger. Carbon offsets allow companies to keep polluting as usual if someone somewhere else does something like plant a tree to offset that pollution on paper.  The carbon cycle doesn’t work that way. Rayner states that we need to make cuts to pollution right now and lay to rest ill-founded idea that counting carbon offsets equals climate action.

The expected costs of climate action are very visible, but we rarely hear about the costs of inaction.  The costs of business as usual (Direct costs of continuing to power ourselves with fossil fuels) alone nearly match the cost to decarbonise our economy.  Added to that are the significant costs of inaction, the indirect costs.  These include the huge and escalating price we will all pay from more unnatural weather disasters which the Insurance Council of Australia estimates will cost about 35 billion dollars a year by 2050 if we keep going on our current path.

An excellent book – recommended reading. - Alec Roberts

In the Media

Solar gardens growing cheap electricity | Newcastle Herald 24 Sep 2018

Lake Mac Is Living Smart
- NBN News 22 Sep 2018

​University of Newcastle rolls out 2MW solar system at Callaghan Campus - RenewEconomy 

University of Newcastle rolls out 2MW solar system at Callaghan Campus - One Step Off The Grid 27 Feb 2018  

University of Newcastle goes solar - Bradman Recruitment Group 26 Feb 2018

University of Newcastle goes solar - Goondiwindi Argus 25 February 2018

Shining light: University of Newcastle goes solar - 
​Newcastle Herald 26 February 2018

Community Energy, where communities take renewable energy into their own hands - The Hunter Business Review 18 September 2017


Success of community energy a win for the world - Newcastle Herald 3 July 2017

Renewable energy island a community triumph - Newcastle Herald 15 May 2017

Meter smarts needed when solar bonus finishes - Newcastle Herald 12 December 2016

Blockchain a win-win for community power trade - Newcastle Herald 21 November 2016

Sun Shines on the Wetlands - Newcastle Herald November 2016

The Wetlander Volume 31 Issue 2 November 2016

Grass roots fertiliser for growth of green energy - Newcastle Herald 6 March 2016

Hunter Wetlands Solar goes live - Newcastle Herald 16 November 2015

Hunter Wetlands celebrates 30 years [and marks a new era of sustainability with 48 solar panels switched on] - NBN News 7 November

The Wetlander Volume 30 Issue 2 November 2015 
 
Tech firms plan to connect - Newcastle Herald 29 June 2015

Hunter Wetlands To Go Solar - Hunter Headline 19 June 2015

OPINION: New call to band together for the Wetlands - Newcastle Herald 8 June 2015

Looking for a thriving Australian renewables sector? Look to community projects - RenewEconomy 5 June 2015

Community solar - Energy from the ground up - ReNew Issue 129 October-December 2014

Kooragang wind turbine sold to Tasmanian poultry farm - Newcastle Herald 15 August 2014

Kooragang wind turbine could be saved to power surf clubs - RenewEconomy 14 July 2014

Do I need to move overseas to work in renewables industry? - RenewEconomy 13 May 2014

Media Releases

Wetlands celebrates 30th Anniversary - Hunter Wetlands Centre 28 October 2015

Hunter Wetlands Goes Solar - Hunter Wetlands Centre 1 July 2015

Submissions

​RET Review - Published Submissions

CLEANaS Submission to the CAMAC in response to the discussion paper on Crowd Sourced Equity Funding